At this point I only keep the ads because I hope it will recover, but hardly earn anything.
This is the only "communication" I get from Google, my actual numbers:
January report: your revenue dropped by 35%. Let's improve it.
December report: your revenue dropped by 14%. Let's improve it.
November report: your revenue dropped by 13%. Let's improve it.
October report: your revenue dropped by 22%. Let's improve it.
I am a publisher for around 15 years and it is my full time job, 16-19 hours a day, I am positive I did everything possible to recover.
I literally hate them now; it is a pain to watch the AdSense advice and tips videos posted by young Google employees on YouTube, these guys were 5-6 years old when I was in the AdSense business, now they get to tell what is right and wrong, what is fraud or legit click.
The contents in error reporting and the help documents are a joke, I am sick of the superiority attitude and lack of communication. Google doesn't deserve it's publishers.
// Sorry for the rant but I had enough :(