Forum Moderators: open

Message Too Old, No Replies

Partner with competitor for SEO purposes

SEO partnerships with competitors

         

timeisenhauer

10:14 pm on Aug 9, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Hi,

Recently, a major competitor of ours approached us about becoming partners to help build each others SEO and search engine rankings.

His site and our site basically have the same type of content, we are in the same industry, and in so many words....we have the same business. We have many many similar pages that seem to 'match up' between the two sites content wise.

His business has been around longer than ours and already appears in the top 10 results in google for the major keywords (which we are both optimizing for).

Here is what he proposed:

On every one of our pages (my site), we put a link to the respective page on his website. For example, he has a page about "Business Books" and so do we....so we would link to each other from these pages. He wants a link from every one of our pages...and he will give a link to us on all of his pages.

Anchor text:
He is proposing that the anchor text for these links should read "partner"

We have about 15,000 pages and he has about 100,000 pages.

It seems that this could help by giving us some deep links into our site, from another site that has relevant content. Each link that we get would have a different URL pointing to a different page on our site. However, we will also be giving him a ton of links, which point away from our site.

Does anyone have any comments, suggestions, questions, etc about this type of deal? How can this help? How can this hurt us? What suggestions do you have to make something like this work?

He is desparately asking for these links, contacting us everyday about this proposal. He says that other sites in our industry are doing this and seeing positive results.

I'm fairly knowledgable about SEO, however this is a bit out of my league and I'm unsure what to do.

1. Either he wants us to be partners and have both of us benefit.
- OR -
2. He wants to KILL our business.

Thanks in advance for your advice.

fischermx

10:17 pm on Aug 9, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



What a strange proposal, be carefull!

LifeinAsia

10:22 pm on Aug 9, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



A few years ago, this strategy might have been okay. Nowadays, it would probably be viewed as link farming and probably result in negative hits for both of you.

If you have other links on that page and he has other links on his page, it might not be so bad. But if every page of his you link to just has a link back to you (besides the content and internal links), that's going to look suspicious. Especially when every single page of your site has a link (with a recipricol link) to his site.

One does wonder about his motivation...

timeisenhauer

10:41 pm on Aug 9, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Thanks for your reply. I am positive that his motivation is to "follow" other players in this industry that are doing this, or something similar.

We have learned to not follow our competitors footsteps in the SEO realm because there is a lot of things that the "BIG" players (that sit at the top of search engines) are doing wrong.

The main reason that the competitors are at the top of the results (our thought) is because of incoming links. So....that is why we are exploring ways to build incoming links from relevant websites.

What are your thoughts if we give him a link from our homepage in exchange for a link on his homepage to us?

thanks again.