Forum Moderators: martinibuster

Message Too Old, No Replies

Ad delivery blocked on a domain for links to torrent sites

Discussion was about internet censorship and not copyright infringement

         

chromaniac

3:53 am on Oct 8, 2014 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



My AdSense account is around 10 years old. The site affected is also around the same age. The infringement is related to links to torrent sites. But the example threads pointed out by Google were discussions related to ISPs blocking access to these sites which is essentially about internet censorship and not copyright infringement.

This is not a new thing. Since the beginning of the forum, we have discussed about internet services, online services and blocking of websites by ISPs in my country. The forum does not allow posting of links pointing to pirated material. But of course, when you talk about censorship, users do link to the sites like The Pirate Bay and such.

My question is… What should I do before filing an appeal? Remove all discussions around file sharing and torrent sites? Or Google only has issues with actual links to these sites? Would it be fine if I kill all active links and keep the name of the sites on my forum?

I am guessing I only get one shot at appealing the ban. What are my chances at getting this block removed?

PS. My account is not banned. Only ad serving to one domain is blocked right now.

Please advise.

graeme_p

4:48 am on Oct 8, 2014 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



As far as I know Google only has an issue with actual links to pirated torrents - and only pirated ones, lots of sites with links to non-breaching torrents are in Google.

Some governments have issues with discussions about torrents (e.g. the full UK "#*$!" blacklist blocks sites with news stories related to piracy), but that is an entirely separate issue.

chromaniac

5:05 am on Oct 8, 2014 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Right. I am currently working on killing all links to TPB and other known torrent and file sharing services. Would file an appeal after that. Hopefully they remove the block because it's stupid. Thanks!

Mentat

6:38 pm on Oct 8, 2014 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



LOL, new TPB has Searchbox in Google :)

[bit.ly...]

chromaniac

4:44 am on Oct 9, 2014 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Right. It's insane that Google publicly is against censorship on the internet. They left the Chinese market because of that. And here they want me to censor all instances of domain names of file sharing and torrent websites even though the discussion is about censorship of these domains and not copyright infringement.

netmeg

2:36 pm on Oct 9, 2014 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



They don't want you to censor them, they just don't want you to run their ads next to them, because in most cases, the advertisers don't want to run ads next to them (in many cases those advertisers are the very ones who feel injured by the torrent sites)

You want to have the discussions with the links, that's fine, have the discussions, but find another way to monetize them (or don't monetize them) This is not a free speech thing. You are not *entitled* to run AdSense on these pages.

chromaniac

2:47 pm on Oct 9, 2014 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



well. google already detect pages with keywords like #*$! and playboy (regular articles including these words in title tag for example) and do not show ads on them. i have seen this happen all the time even on my own blogs. they could technically do the same with file sharing related content right? :)

i removed links. even blocked keywords related to torrent search engines and file sharing services. the appeal was still rejected. i have now deleted entire threads and now waiting for response to second appeal.