1. Home
  2. Forums Index
  3. Search Engines and SEO / Google Search and SEO 11:57 pm May 20, 2026

Forum Moderators: Robert Charlton & goodroi

Ranking in Reddit

         

wheel

12:52 am on Feb 23, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Really just a bleat about stuff that's well known, and similiar to stuff that has variously worked years ago:
I ranked in a competitive industry for about 15 years. Sold that about 5 years ago, they immediately killed the rankings. A few years ago I decided to get back into that industry. At that time I looked at ranking again as a source of traffic. Decided not to because it's pretty much impossible to get a ton of good quality links. Played around, but didn't put full effort, so I don't rank. Looked into becoming a source for AI responses, decided that wasn't worth the effort.

However, one think I do, is post on reddit. And I post quality content in response to redditor's questions. And I'm consistent enough that if my topic comes up, I likely have a comment in the responses, and my comment is likely exhaustive. My username on reddit is just my company name, and I never post links to my site, entice anyone to visit, suggest someone contact me, or even indicate I'm in the industry. I just answer the question, professionally and authoritatively.

The reason that's worth a post here? Because right now, reddit posts are ranking quite well in Google. Including on some of the most competitive search terms. Top 20 responses are fortune 100 companies and one reddit thread. And when you click through on the reddit thread..........there's my comment upvoted to number one. I just saw this on three of the most important search terms in my industry. So I'm ranking in google, just one click away. On some of the terms that I used to make an entire business from lol. And on those google listings, they'll point out the thread then they'll also post right on the main serps page, selections from the comments. Hmmmmm.

So, there's something to be said about getting top upvoted on a reddit post that gets ranked in Google. That leads to two thoughts:
- how do I figure out what posts will get ranked in Google. Or, how do I get a reddit post ranked in Google. That's probably not knoweable, but it's certainly something I'm thinking of. Maybe upvotes, but I'm sceptical.
- how do I get upvoted.

So some thoughts. In the olden days, people would blast links to secondary sites that then pointed to their main site. If the secondary sites got blasted, your main site might not. Similarly, I could blast links or upvotes to a post someone else has made, that I'm the top comment on.
I could also make my own PSA posts with some search engine friendly content. I've done those types of informational posts in the past but not with an eye to getting the post ranked in Google.
I could buy upvotes, but I'm not so sure I'm going to do that. I don't like that level of risk when my username is my company name However I bet I could put together a 20 plus group of people from my kids' friend group and give them all $10 for upvoting me once in a while, either my posts or my comments.
I also think any such strategy needs to be differentated between posts that I do, vs posts that others have done, vs comments that I make. Upvoting my comments is different than upvoting posts, with different intentions. And lastly, gotta think about what I can do to get my comments prominently displayed and clickable when they do show up in the serps. No idea, probably just some clickable words or calls to action maybe. ("Let me explain everything you need to know about this..." or something).

I mostly posted because I saw a lot of similiarities between this and some of the real old school fringe seo techniques from like 15 years ago.

Kendo

2:58 am on Feb 23, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Yes, a few sites rank highly whether they are authoritative on the topic or not. My guess is that those sites pay for ads and Google criteria is not anything like what they claim. Consequently Reddit, Quora and Slack Exchange always fare well with Wikipedia usually at #1... just the mere inclusion of your keyword/s gets them on page 1.

Something that I noticed the other day was that while it is almost impossible to get a company page at Wikipedia even for the inventor and leading innovator in their field, that a hit man for a bikie gang can get a page devoted to them by simply getting mentioned in a tabloid article.

Slack Exchange roast authoritative answers in favour of scraped solutions posted by a few regulars. I was banned from Quora for posting authoritative answers and I wouldn't touch Reddit without a hazmat suit.

Whitey

5:35 am on Feb 23, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



What you're seeing isn't accidental, and it isn't manipulation. it's a structural shift in how Google evaluates trust and experience.

TL:DNR Reddit ranks because Google now prioritizes demonstrated experience and engagement signals over traditional site-level authority alone.

Key points based on observed behavior and Google's own direction:

Google explicitly boosted forums (including Reddit) starting around 2023 via the “Hidden Gems” and forum prioritization systems. This wasn’t subtle, Reddit visibility increased dramatically across commercial and informational SERPs.

Google is ranking experience, not just websites. A highly upvoted, detailed Reddit comment functions like an expert mini-page. In many cases, Google extracts and shows the comment itself in SERPs or AI summaries.

Reddit’s domain authority is overwhelming. The site has millions of natural backlinks, continuous fresh content, and extremely strong engagement metrics. Individual threads inherit this trust automatically.

Engagement is the key multiplier. Threads that rank tend to have:
– strong keyword match in the title
– early engagement velocity
– sustained comment activity
– high dwell time

Upvotes help indirectly because they increase visibility and engagement, which Google measures.

Google is heavily favoring authentic human responses over commercial SEO content. Reddit answers often solve real problems without conversion intent, which aligns with Google's current quality targets.

Comments can effectively rank as independent authority nodes. Being the top comment in a ranking thread is functionally equivalent to ranking on page 1, especially when Google surfaces comment excerpts directly.

This is scalable if done consistently. Posting authoritative responses in threads that already align with high-volume search queries is currently one of the most efficient ways to gain SERP visibility without owning the ranking page.

Trying to artificially manipulate upvotes is unnecessary and risky. Threads that rank organically tend to do so because they genuinely satisfy search intent and sustain engagement over time.

Most important takeaway:

You're not really "ranking Reddit." You're ranking your demonstrated expertise, and Reddit is acting as the authority host that Google trusts.

This is very similar to how Google historically ranked authoritative forum posts; just at much greater scale now.

Kendo

1:01 pm on Feb 23, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Nah. What you are seeing is sites handpicked by Google as filler for fools. Proof of that can be seen by how remotely related posts are seen on page 1 of search results.

If Google metrics were even a little bit as good as what they claim and what we keep reading about, sites like Reddiit wouldn't get a show.

Dress it up as much as you like - it's still garbage.

Whitey

10:34 pm on Feb 24, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



@Kendo - this isn’t about ads or hand-picking. If it were, rankings wouldn’t fluctuate based on thread engagement, freshness, and relevance; but they do, consistently.

What’s happening is simpler:

Google is trying to rank the most useful answers. Reddit happens to produce those answers frequently because they’re written by practitioners without commercial filtering.

That doesn’t mean Reddit is perfect, but it does mean Google trusts large-scale human experience signals more than isolated commercial pages.

Practical takeaway for anyone here:

You can still rank your expertise, even if you don’t rank your site, by consistently contributing authoritative answers in threads that align with real search queries.

In the current environment, that’s often faster and more reliable than traditional SEO alone.

Kendo

3:37 am on Feb 25, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Google is trying to rank the most useful answers.

The proof is in the pudding - which shows that they either have no idea how to do that properly, or that they are indeed blatantly cooking the results for their own benefit.

Reddit happens to produce those answers frequently because they’re written by practitioners without commercial filtering.

I have yet to seen any evidence of that. And that is all I will say about self-proclaimed experts who have never been anywhere, not done anything of consequence and most likely never will. How the inclusion of anything so unrelated can be selected as being authoritative, especially when there is so much more out there, demands a better explanation than what has been borrowed from propaganda.

Two decades and billions of dollars spent on spun excuses and disinformation does not change the fact search results are still adulterated garbage.

Whitey

4:31 am on Feb 25, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



@Kendo I understand the frustration. Many of us who ranked successfully under the old link-authority model have seen that advantage diluted.

TL;DNR: Reddit ranks not because Google can perfectly identify expertise, but because large-scale user interaction provides measurable feedback loops that correlate strongly with usefulness.

A few important distinctions:

• Google doesn’t actually know who is an expert. It never has. What it measures instead are behavioral proxies, interaction, engagement, consistency, and whether users continue searching or stop.

• Reddit provides unusually strong behavioral signals at scale. Threads accumulate:
– thousands of independent users
– voting feedback
– replies, corrections, and disagreement
– continuous updates over time

This creates a self-correcting signal environment that static commercial pages don’t have.

• Commercial pages are structurally biased. They’re optimized for conversion, affiliate revenue, or lead generation. Even when accurate, users treat them with more skepticism, and Google can detect that behavior indirectly.

• Reddit threads often persist because users find them satisfactory, not because Google assumes they are authoritative. If users didn’t engage with them or returned immediately to search, they wouldn’t hold rankings.

• This isn’t a perfect system; it’s probabilistic. Google is optimizing for aggregate usefulness across billions of queries, not correctness in every individual case.

The key shift is this:

Google has moved from primarily trusting publisher authority to trusting observed user response at scale.

That inevitably elevates platforms like Reddit, because they generate continuous, real-world feedback signals.

Practical reality for publishers:

The algorithm isn’t rewarding Reddit itself; it’s rewarding environments where usefulness can be continuously measured.

Independent sites can still compete, but they now need to generate equivalent trust signals through engagement, brand recognition, and user interaction, not links alone.

This explains why @wheel’s observation is repeatable: his answers are ranking because users find them useful, and Reddit provides the infrastructure for Google to detect that

Whitey

4:46 am on Feb 25, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



I thought I’d add this:

TL;DNR: Reddit gives Google direct, large-scale feedback signals about usefulness that most standalone websites cannot provide reliably.

Google can’t read minds or verify expertise directly. Instead, it measures user behavior patterns. Reddit happens to expose those patterns very clearly.

Key signals Reddit provides:

1. Independent quality voting at scale
Upvotes and downvotes from unrelated users act as distributed quality feedback. This isn’t perfect, but statistically it correlates strongly with perceived usefulness over large sample sizes.

2. Engagement depth and persistence
Google can observe whether users:
– click a Reddit result
– stay and scroll
– expand comments
– follow discussion chains
– or return immediately to search

Threads where users stay longer tend to rank more consistently.

3. Multi-party validation and correction
Unlike static pages, Reddit answers get challenged, refined, or corrected by others. This creates a continuously updated consensus layer, which increases reliability over time.

4. Freshness combined with stability
Reddit continuously produces new content, but older high-quality threads continue receiving engagement. This allows Google to observe both immediate usefulness and long-term value.

5. Natural language matching real user queries
Reddit questions and answers closely mirror how real users search. This improves query matching compared to heavily optimized commercial pages.

6. Author behavior consistency over time
Accounts that repeatedly produce useful responses develop a measurable engagement history. Google doesn’t need to know who the person is — it can observe how users respond to their content over time.

7. Lower commercial bias signals
Most Reddit content isn’t directly monetized. Users interact differently with informational content versus commercial pages, and those behavioral differences are measurable.

Most important point:

Google isn’t ranking Reddit because it’s Reddit. It’s ranking Reddit because Reddit exposes large-scale, real-world user feedback signals that are difficult to replicate on standalone sites.

Standalone sites can still rank — but they need to generate equivalent trust signals through brand recognition, repeat visitation, and user engagement over time.

This is why @wheel’s experience is repeatable: when useful expertise appears inside an environment with strong feedback signals, Google can detect and reward it more easily.

Kendo

1:34 am on Feb 26, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Again, after all the praise and self-promoting claims about how wonderful their metrics are, search results are still adulterated garbage.

As for Reddit, they are no different any well populated forum - arm chair experts voicing their opinion. So how about doing a real search on a topic and have look to see how often it can be the only comment on that topic, how unrelated to your full search term it was. Then look at the author of that post to wonder how such a bigoted uninformed comment was ever accepted.

Whitey

11:21 pm on Feb 26, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



There are certainly imperfections with Reddit. One that stands out to me in my experience is conflict of interest from some mods (maybe acting against their own biases), stamping out anything that looks as though it will dominate a community with top quality knowledge and contributions. Although Google may use it as "strong" signals, as I've outlined above, the reality is far from perfect.

Personally, i think Google has to get better at blending results.

With all of these thoughts, imo search is not designed to give you exactly what you want. AI and search systems, as well as Reddit, don't give you that, otherwise what's the point of having advertising as a business model. The systems are designed to create participation and ambiguity, otherwise why would you bother searching. Maybe, I've missed the point, but that's my view FWIW.

Whitey

12:37 am on Feb 27, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Worth reading: [bbc.com...]

Kendo

1:56 am on Feb 28, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



says Reddit is useful for advice about pets

And this makes them authoritative on all things pertaining to the universe.

tangor

3:10 am on Mar 5, 2026 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Hey kiddies!

Just follow the money!

That's the answer---and has been since Methuselah was a pup!
 

Join The Conversation

Moderators and Top Contributors

Hot Threads This Week

  1. Home
  2. Forums Index
  3. Search Engines and SEO / Google Search and SEO 11:57 pm May 20, 2026