Forum Moderators: rogerd

Message Too Old, No Replies

Forum registration for backlinks

dirty trick for SEO

         

cameraman

8:00 pm on Jun 21, 2008 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I didn't do a search for this first so my apologies if it's been covered. And I put it here instead of search engines since it applies to us as web masters as opposed to us as rank improvers.

A couple of weeks ago I noticed that someone had actually registered for my forum. Inasmuch as it's been up for over 2 years now and no one's ever registered, I was naturally aquiver with anticipation. When I first saw it, the user hadn't completed the email-based activation. The next day it was activated, but then this person never got around to posting anything. Finally yesterday I figured out why, and I googled the user name. Sure enough, this user name has registered for a great number of forums, never posting anything at any of them.

The person had filled in the 'home page' section of the profile (at mine and everywhere else). Since the nosy search engines are always probing everyone's profiles, this would get picked up as a backlink to the person's site.

I altered my forum. There's a 'newest user' line at page bottom; I changed that so that the user name won't show up until after a post. I also changed the profile page so that the web address won't become clickable until after an arbitrary number of posts. And finally, I changed the member list page so that the WWW column doesn't get filled in until the same arbitrary number of posts has been made.

I thought you cats might be interested in the info. Personally I think it's a dirty trick, and while it doesn't really "cost" me anything, I still feel used since I am most certainly not getting my own backlink out of the deal.

Marcia

9:38 pm on Jun 21, 2008 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I fully understand what you're saying, and it's a darn shame that more forum admins don't place restrictions on who does and doesn't get backlinks.

Unfortunately, there don't seem to be good guidelines drawn up between being SAVVY and being a SAP, and sad to say, most fall into the latter category.

thecoalman

1:53 am on Jun 22, 2008 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



This is pretty common, depending on your forum there is few things you can do such as some of the modifications you have used. There was one mod for phpbb2 that actually used it against the spammers. A lot of bots are programmed to fill out the website field automatically. The mod removed this field from the registration form so a human wouldn't be filling it out, for any submission that had the website address field it banned the IP immediately.

phpbb3 takes all incentive away for a bot to register other than to spam posts, SE bots are treated as members with their own group and own set of permissions. Links to the memberlist page or a profile are not parsed as links. A SE bot trying to load either the memberlist page or a profile will get a "You do not have permission to access this page". Signatures are hidden by deafualt as well. the only place they can spam links is in posts.